AltMountain

Stilwell Value LLC

New York, NY · CRD 160697
Hedge fund manager

Stilwell Value LLC is an SEC-registered investment adviser based in New York, NY that reports managing 5 hedge funds on Form ADV. It reports $278.7 million in regulatory assets under management. Its private funds, of all types, hold $278.7 million in gross assets. Its disclosed U.S. stock holdings returned an estimated +2.1% 2026 YTD through Jun 30 (S&P 500: +9.5%), based on 13F filings. Over a longer period they returned an estimated +53.7% from Q3 2024 to Q2 2026, compared with +37.2% for the S&P 500, based on 13F filings.

Regulatory assets under management
$278.7 millionForm ADV Item 5.F
Gross assets of private funds
$278.7 millionAll private fund types, Form ADV
Hedge funds managed
55 private funds in total
Employees
11Form ADV Item 5.A
Registration
SEC-registered adviserCRD 160697
Latest Form ADV
03/27/2026Disciplinary disclosures: yes, see SEC record

Estimated 13F portfolio performance

Estimated by AltMountain, derived from the firm’s public Form 13F filings. Not reported by the firm and not the return of any fund.

Estimated from 13F · 2026 YTD+2.1%Through Q2 2026 · S&P 500 +9.5%
Estimated from 13F · 2 years+53.7%Q3 2024 – Q2 2026
S&P 500+37.2%Same quarters, price only
13F holdings$174.4 million24 positions, 2026-06-30
$100$137$174Q3 2024Q1 2025Q3 2025Q1 202613F est. $154S&P 500 $137
QuarterEst. 13F returnS&P 500
Q2 2026+6.9%+14.8%
Q1 2026-4.5%-4.6%
Q4 2025-9.2%+2.4%
Q3 2025-4.7%+7.8%
Q2 2025+16.2%+10.4%
Q1 2025+30.9%-4.5%
Q4 2024-3.8%+2.1%
Q3 2024+18.8%+5.4%

Estimate of the firm's disclosed long U.S. stock portfolio from its quarterly 13F filings, holding each quarter-end portfolio to the next quarter-end at prices implied by all 13F filers. It is a price return before dividends and fees, ignores shorts, options, bonds, cash and trading within the quarter, and is not the return of any fund. Disclosures

Manager of this firm? Report your fund’s actual net return, or email hello@altmountain.com to correct or remove this estimate. Removal requests from the firm are honored.

13F holdings as of Sep 30, 2026

All 26 share positions ($174,905,944) reported by Stilwell Value LLC on Form 13F for the quarter ended Sep 30, 2026, filed Nov 16, 2026. Shown as filed with the SEC. Original filing on SEC.gov ↗ The estimated return above runs through Jun 30, 2026; it is updated when the SEC publishes its complete data for the quarter.

Share of the reported 13F portfolio, ten largest positions

  • Wheeler Real Estate Invt TR41.39%
  • Kingsway Corp17.73%
  • Sound Finl Bancorp Inc10.47%
  • Lake Shore Bancorp Inc8.03%
  • Central Plains Bancshares In4.58%
  • Catalyst Bancorp Inc3.67%
  • Wheeler Real Estate Invt TR3.17%
  • FS Bancorp Inc1.73%
  • Northeast Cmnty Bancorp Inc1.49%
  • <![cdata[wheeler Real Estate Invt TR]]>1.35%
StockValue% of 13F portfolioSharesShares vs prior quarter
Wheeler Real Estate Invt TR$72,394,75541.39%851,703-1.62%
Kingsway Corp$31,002,77517.73%3,263,450-2.97%
Sound Finl Bancorp Inc$18,307,34810.47%410,019Unchanged
Lake Shore Bancorp Inc$14,049,9388.03%773,675Unchanged
Central Plains Bancshares In$8,010,6034.58%400,130-1.66%
Catalyst Bancorp Inc$6,415,1783.67%364,085Unchanged
Wheeler Real Estate Invt TR$5,550,4063.17%621,546-12.52%
FS Bancorp Inc$3,030,3001.73%70,000Unchanged
Northeast Cmnty Bancorp Inc$2,603,0001.49%100,000Unchanged
<![cdata[wheeler Real Estate Invt TR]]>$2,367,2091.35%728,372New
Home Fed Bancorp Inc La New$1,981,6001.13%80,000Unchanged
BV Finl Inc$1,678,4000.96%80,000Unchanged
Fifth Dist Bancorp Inc$1,384,8000.79%80,000Unchanged
NB Bancorp Inc$1,106,0000.63%50,000Unchanged
Magyar Bancorp Inc$762,0000.44%40,000Unchanged
<![cdata[rhinebeck Bancorp Inc]]>$761,4000.44%60,000New
Avidia Bancorp Inc$756,0000.43%35,000Unchanged
Space Exploration Techn Corp$754,3000.43%5,000Unchanged
Ecb Bancorp Inc$405,8000.23%20,000Unchanged
Ponce Financial Group Inc$398,8000.23%20,000Unchanged
FB Bancorp Inc$329,6000.19%20,000Unchanged
Marathon Bancorp Inc$300,0000.17%20,000Unchanged
Proshares TR II$267,6400.15%4,000Unchanged
<![cdata[columbia Finl Inc]]>$221,2000.13%20,000New
Principal Financial Group In$61,2420.03%547Unchanged
Metlife Inc$5,6500.00%60Unchanged

Changes since Jun 30, 2026

Comparing the share counts in the two quarter-end filings: 3 new positions, 1 sold out, 0 increased, 4 reduced and 19 unchanged.

Number of positions (a count, not dollars)

  • New positions3
  • Increased0
  • Unchanged19
  • Reduced4
  • Sold out1

New positions

StockValueShares
<![cdata[wheeler Real Estate Invt TR]]>$2,367,209728,372
<![cdata[rhinebeck Bancorp Inc]]>$761,40060,000
<![cdata[columbia Finl Inc]]>$221,20020,000

Sold out

StockValue at Jun 30, 2026Shares held then
Wheeler Real Estate Invt TR$1,9791,583

Largest reductions

StockChange in sharesChangeValue nowShares now
Wheeler Real Estate Invt TR-14,018-1.62%$72,394,755851,703
Kingsway Corp-100,000-2.97%$31,002,7753,263,450
Wheeler Real Estate Invt TR-88,920-12.52%$5,550,406621,546
Central Plains Bancshares In-6,744-1.66%$8,010,603400,130

Each list shows up to 20 positions, largest first by dollar amount. Changes compare two quarter-end snapshots, with the earlier share count adjusted for stock splits AltMountain detected. They do not show when, or at what price, anything was bought or sold.

From public Form 13F filings, not verified. Form 13F is filed up to 45 days after the quarter ends, so positions may have changed. It lists only certain long positions in U.S.-listed stocks and exchange-traded funds; options are not shown here, and short positions, most bonds, cash, non-U.S. securities and private investments are not reported at all, so a holding may be one side of a hedge. A filing covers the manager as a whole, not any single fund, and filings contain errors. This is not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Disclosures

Hedge funds filing Form D (1)

Matched to this firm by the fund names and related persons in each Form D. The list may be incomplete.

Private funds reported on Form ADV (5)

Fund
Gross assets
Minimum
Owners
Adviser
Stilwell Activist Investments, LP
Delaware, United StatesHedge fund
Gross assets$149M
Minimum$500K
Owners74
AdviserStilwell Value LLC
Stilwell Partners, LP
Delaware, United StatesHedge fund
Gross assets$37.0M
Minimum$100K
Owners44
AdviserStilwell Value LLC
Stilwell Value Partners VII, LP
Delaware, United StatesHedge fund
Gross assets$29.3M
Minimum$100K
Owners2
AdviserStilwell Value LLC
Stilwell Activist Fund, LP
Delaware, United StatesHedge fund
Gross assets$22.6M
Minimum$100K
Owners47
AdviserStilwell Value LLC
Stilwell Associates, LP
Delaware, United StatesHedge fund
Gross assets$12.6M
Minimum$100K
Owners11
AdviserStilwell Value LLC

As reported in the adviser's Form ADV filed Oct 2, 2024. Funds also listed from Form D are shown above.

From SEC filings. Firm data comes from the SEC's Form ADV data as of Oct 2, 2026; performance estimates come from Form 13F. AltMountain has not verified this information, and it is not an offer, solicitation or recommendation. Full disclosures⁠​​‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​​​​​​‌​⁠